Ethical rules and intuitions cannot successfully be formulated in quantifiable measures.

Question

Answer

Pro: Ethical decisions in medicine often require compassion and a personal understanding of the degree of pain or suffering that patients are experiencing.

Answer

Pro: Everyday moral decision-making often involves complex cost-benefit analyses, which treat individual dilemmas as unique cases. This reasoning cannot be distilled into objective metrics.

Should human doctors be replaced by automated ones? (ANTI-Automation)

Ethical rules and intuitions cannot successfully be formulated in quantifiable measures.

Pros

Cons

Ethical decisions in medicine often require compassion and a personal understanding of the degree of pain or suffering that patients are experiencing.

Everyday moral decision-making often involves complex cost-benefit analyses, which treat individual dilemmas as unique cases. This reasoning cannot be distilled into objective metrics.

Selected claim, opposing its parent

Ethical rules and intuitions cannot successfully be formulated in quantifiable measures.

Pro claim 1

Ethical decisions in medicine often require compassion and a personal understanding of the degree of pain or suffering that patients are experiencing.

Pro claim 2

Everyday moral decision-making often involves complex cost-benefit analyses, which treat individual dilemmas as unique cases. This reasoning cannot be distilled into objective metrics.