In the “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” is King’s criticism of the White moderate fair?

Loading Discussion

Selected thesis

Martin Luther King’s criticism of the White moderate is fair.

Pros

Cons

  • Pro claim 1

    Unoppressed people have no right to criticize oppressed people’s approach to liberation.

  • Pro claim 2

    The White moderate lacks moral conviction.

  • Con claim 1

    It is wrong to blame people for wanting peace and stability.

  • Con claim 2

    The White moderate was not as much an impediment to racial justice as groups of committed racists.