Kialo requires JavaScript to work correctly.
Should Confederate war dead be excluded from Memorial Day observances?
Loading Discussion
Selected thesis
Confederate soldiers should be excluded from Memorial Day observances.
Pros
Cons
Pro claim 1
Confederate soldiers were not US soldiers.
Pro claim 2
The Confederacy is too closely associated with slavery for its soldiers to be included in Memorial Day.
Con claim 1
Including Confederate soldiers in Memorial Day is an important step to reconciliation.
Con claim 2
Excluding Confederate soldiers from Memorial Day is an erasure of history.
Log In
Sign Up