Healthcare is a universal right.

Question

Answer

Pro: Capabilities theories advocate for universal healthcare because universal healthcare is necessary for individuals to live their lives to the best of their abilities.

Answer

Pro: From the communitarian conception of justice, making healthcare a universal right would benefit the most people.

Answer

Con: According to libertarian theories of justice, healthcare should not be a universal right.

Answer

Pro: According to well-being theories, healthcare should be a universal right.

Answer

Con: According to utilitarian theories of justice healthcare should only be a universal right if it maximizes total utility.

Answer

Con: According to the egalitarian doctrine, healthcare should not be a universal right.

Demo Classroom Debate: Medical Ethics

Healthcare is a universal right.

Pros

Cons

From the communitarian conception of justice, making healthcare a universal right would benefit the most people.

Capabilities theories advocate for universal healthcare because universal healthcare is necessary for individuals to live their lives to the best of their abilities.

According to well-being theories, healthcare should be a universal right.

According to libertarian theories of justice, healthcare should not be a universal right.

According to utilitarian theories of justice healthcare should only be a universal right if it maximizes total utility.

According to the egalitarian doctrine, healthcare should not be a universal right.

Selected thesis

Healthcare is a universal right.

Pro claim 1, children below

From the communitarian conception of justice, making healthcare a universal right would benefit the most people.

Pro claim 2, children below

Capabilities theories advocate for universal healthcare because universal healthcare is necessary for individuals to live their lives to the best of their abilities.

Pro claim 3, children below

According to well-being theories, healthcare should be a universal right.

Con claim 1, children below

According to libertarian theories of justice, healthcare should not be a universal right.

Con claim 2, children below

According to utilitarian theories of justice healthcare should only be a universal right if it maximizes total utility.

Con claim 3, children below

According to the egalitarian doctrine, healthcare should not be a universal right.